In recent years, the economic ties between Russia and Iran have gained attention as both nations, facing international sanctions, seek to strengthen cooperation in sectors like energy, trade, and finance. With an anticipated comprehensive strategic agreement set to be signed soon, discussions surrounding the future of Russian-Iranian economic relations have intensified. While the political partnership between these two nations is well-documented, their economic relationship has been historically underdeveloped. Despite new initiatives, the path forward remains fraught with challenges, raising critical questions about the prospects for substantial economic growth between the two countries.

Before the establishment of the Islamic Republic of Iran in 1979, economic relations between Iran and the Soviet Union were relatively limited. Iran’s trade partnerships with Western countries like the United States, Japan, and Europe far outstripped its exchanges with the USSR. The Soviet Union did provide some assistance, such as helping establish the Esfahan Steel Company in exchange for Iranian gas, but overall, the economic relationship remained constrained.

The Iranian Revolution did not significantly alter this trajectory. Over the past four decades, trade between Iran and Russia has remained modest, despite periodic increases. In comparison to their respective trade volumes with other global partners, the economic exchange between the two countries has always been minor. For example, in 2022, Russia’s global trade volume was nearly $800 billion, while its trade with Iran amounted to less than $3 billion-an insignificant figure considering the potential scope of their economic cooperation.

Iran’s exports to Russia have never surpassed $500 million annually between 1992 and 2018, with a slight increase recorded in 2021 when exports reached around $920 million. Russian exports to Iran have similarly been inconsistent, fluctuating between $190 million in 1993 and a peak of $1.7 billion in 2021. However, by 2022, Russian exports had decreased to just $1.15 billion. Even during periods of trade growth, the bilateral exchange remained a small fraction of their respective global trade volumes. In 2023, the trade volume had fallen below $2 billion, placing Iran as Russia’s 41st largest trading partner.

In contrast, Iran’s trade with other countries has been far more robust. For instance, Iran’s trade with India reached nearly $17 billion in 2018, while its global trade volume was about $80 billion in 2022. This illustrates Iran’s more prominent economic ties with countries outside Russia, demonstrating the relatively insignificant role that Russia plays in Iran’s broader economic landscape.

A crucial area of focus in the relationship between Russia and Iran is energy, especially natural gas. Iran’s vast reserves require at least $200 billion in foreign investment to develop its oil and gas industries, but Russia has not been a significant investor in these sectors. In fact, other nations such as China, Turkiye, India, Afghanistan, and the UAE have outpaced Russia in investments in Iran. Despite signing an agreement with Gazprom worth $40 billion in 2022, concrete results from this deal have yet to materialize.

The political alliance between Russia and Iran, particularly in military and security affairs, has not translated into corresponding economic gains. The two nations signed a 20-year strategic agreement in 2001, which was renewed in 2020 for an additional five years. This agreement largely focused on security and energy collaboration, but its impact on their economic ties was limited. The same pattern may apply to the upcoming comprehensive strategic agreement.

One of the primary obstacles to deepening economic cooperation is the sanctions both nations face, particularly from the United States and other Western countries. These sanctions have severely restricted their ability to expand trade, attract foreign investments, and transfer technology. Although Russia and Iran have attempted to establish alternative financial payment systems to mitigate the impact of sanctions, these efforts have yet to yield substantial results.

In addition, Russia’s economic involvement in Iran pales in comparison to other global players. The top five investors in Iran-China, Turkiye, Afghanistan, India, and the UAE-accounted for about $4 billion in investments in Iran’s 2023-24 fiscal year. Russia, despite being a strategic political ally, was not among these top investors, except in 2022-23, when it made a one-time investment of $2.8 billion in Iran’s energy and mining sectors. This investment, though significant, is far from sufficient to meet Iran’s broader economic needs.

Another factor complicating Russian-Iranian economic ties is the underlying political differences that occasionally emerge between the two nations. While they share common ground in confronting Western pressures, their relationship is often more transactional than strategic. Geopolitical differences, such as divergent interests in the Middle East, occasionally undermine trust between Moscow and Tehran.

Iran’s motivations for maintaining relations with Russia are pragmatic. It sees Russia as a useful counterbalance to Western influence, but Tehran has also shown a willingness to engage with Western countries when the opportunity arises. This has led some analysts to speculate that Iran could shift its alliances depending on its long-term strategic interests, potentially at the expense of its partnership with Russia.

While the upcoming comprehensive strategic agreement between Russia and Iran signals a desire to strengthen economic ties, it is unlikely to bring about a dramatic shift. The historical underdevelopment of their economic relationship, compounded by sanctions and mutual political hesitations, suggests that significant growth will remain elusive unless both nations can find innovative ways to circumvent external pressures.

Both countries are also exploring alternatives to break out of their international isolation. Organizations such as the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO), the Eurasian Economic Union (EEU), and BRICS, which includes China, provide opportunities for Russia and Iran to form coalitions that may mitigate the effects of Western sanctions. However, these efforts remain in their early stages and are unlikely to yield immediate results.

In conclusion, despite the political alignment between Russia and Iran, their economic ties remain modest. Energy, particularly natural gas, offers some promise, but the broader economic relationship is unlikely to see significant progress in the near future. Internal challenges and external pressures, such as sanctions, continue to stifle the potential for deeper economic cooperation. As both nations navigate a complex geopolitical landscape, their economic partnership will likely remain transactional and limited in scope.

Please follow Blitz on Google News Channel