As Western democracies grapple with internal divisions, economic challenges, and growing disillusionment, the political landscape across the United States, Europe, and other parts of the West has increasingly become a battleground for ideological, economic, and geopolitical struggles. Central to this crisis are the escalating proxy wars in Palestine and Ukraine, which have served to further divide political opinion while reinforcing the influence of global elites on Western politics.
In the United States, the 2024 Presidential election is set against the backdrop of Donald Trump and Kamala Harris’s political rivalry. Both candidates have reaffirmed their support for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government, despite Israel’s controversial military actions in Gaza and the West Bank. Their ongoing backing of Ukraine’s Zelensky regime, albeit less enthusiastic, also reflects the US’s broader geopolitical strategy of countering Russian influence in Eastern Europe. These foreign policy stances align with the interests of global elites, who continue to support American interventionism.
However, it is Donald Trump, the former President and convicted felon, who has dominated the narrative of this election. His audacious claims of a stolen 2020 election and role in inciting the Capitol insurrection on January 6, 2021, once deemed politically disqualifying, now seem less significant to his base of supporters. Over 70 million Americans voted for Trump in 2020, and many remain loyal to him, reinforcing the deep ideological split that characterizes modern American politics.
Trump’s platform of lies, revenge, and inflammatory rhetoric has transformed the 2024 race into a spectacle of polarizing extremes. Yet Kamala Harris, the Democratic nominee, has opted not to dwell on Trump’s transgressions. Instead, her campaign has focused on ridiculing Trump’s personality rather than addressing his attacks on democratic institutions. Harris’s strategy may reflect a broader resignation within the Democratic Party: that condemning Trump’s behavior no longer resonates with a large segment of American voters. Her message of unity-while politically attractive-appears disconnected from the fractured reality of modern America.
As polling shows Harris with a slight lead, the outcome remains uncertain. Trump’s base is energized, and his prediction of a “bloodbath” should he lose suggests that political violence could erupt, further weakening the fabric of American democracy. Regardless of who wins, the divisions that have plagued the US for the last decade will likely only deepen, making Harris’s hopes of national unity seem more like fantasy than feasible policy.
The United Kingdom is no stranger to political instability. Keir Starmer, newly elected as the country’s Labour prime minister, has already reversed his pre-election promises of a new era of prosperity. Instead, he has warned of at least a decade of austerity as Britain struggles to recover from economic decline. Starmer’s pivot to austerity, coupled with cuts like the removal of winter energy payments to pensioners, has stirred unrest among the Labour backbench and diminished his government’s initial popularity.
Starmer’s steadfast commitment to supporting America’s proxy wars, especially in Palestine and Ukraine, contrasts with the growing unease among the British public, many of whom oppose these interventions. Anti-immigrant riots across several UK cities highlight the nation’s rising discontent, reflecting the broader socio-economic pressures that have left many feeling disenfranchised.
As Labour’s support wanes, the Conservative Party remains in disarray, lacking a clear leader or direction. In this vacuum, populist figures like Nigel Farage could capitalize on growing public dissatisfaction, possibly leading to a surge in support for the Reform Party. Whether this political discontent translates into violent protest or electoral shifts remains to be seen, but the warning signs are clear: the UK is facing a period of political turbulence that could challenge the very foundations of its democratic institutions.
Germany’s political landscape, already fragile due to the economic fallout from the Ukraine conflict, has reached a tipping point. The Scholz coalition government, comprised of Social Democrats, Free Democrats, and Greens, has seen its popularity collapse. The recent regional elections in Thuringia and Saxony, where right-wing populist Alternative for Germany (AfD) and left-wing populist BSW gained significant support, signal a major shift in German politics.
The AfD’s 30 percent vote share and BSW’s 15 percent reflect widespread dissatisfaction with Scholz’s policies, particularly his government’s unwavering support for Ukraine. Scholz’s characterization of the AfD as a “right-wing extremist” party mirrors broader attempts by mainstream political elites to dismiss populist movements as illegitimate, but this strategy may backfire. The refusal of mainstream parties to form coalitions with the AfD, despite its electoral success, risks further alienating large swaths of the German electorate and exacerbating political instability.
The rise of populism in Germany is symptomatic of a deeper political realignment, one in which both left and right-wing populist movements challenge the traditional centrist order. These movements, driven by opposition to mass immigration and globalized economic policies, represent a growing challenge to the liberal democratic consensus that has dominated Western Europe for decades.
France, too, is grappling with political paralysis. President Emmanuel Macron’s decision to call an early election backfired, resulting in a fragmented National Assembly where centrist parties have lost their dominance. The rise of a radical left-wing bloc and continued support for the right-wing National Rally have created a stalemate, with each faction holding roughly 30 percent of the vote.
Macron’s decision to appoint conservative politician Michel Barnier as prime minister has further polarized the political landscape. The left-wing bloc’s rejection of Barnier as illegitimate has led to accusations that Macron “stole the election,” adding fuel to the political crisis. France’s inability to form a stable government amidst this divisiveness points to a deepening political instability that could have lasting consequences.
In Australia, political instability is similarly on the rise. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese’s Labor government, holding only a slim two-seat majority, is contending with growing unpopularity. Albanese’s unwavering support for the Netanyahu government in Israel has created deep divisions within the Labor Party, particularly among Muslim voters, many of whom have abandoned the party in key districts.
Unlike the US and Europe, Australia has yet to witness the rise of a significant populist party. However, with growing disillusionment among voters, the upcoming 2025 election could see a hung parliament, forcing Labor into a minority government and heightening political instability.
The political instability in the West is symptomatic of larger global forces at play. The collapse of traditional centrist parties and the rise of populist movements on both the left and right can be traced back to the economic and social dislocation caused by globalization. As the global economy shifts toward renewable energy and technological innovation, the traditional working class and segments of the older middle class have been left behind.
This economic displacement has fostered fierce ideological conflicts in the West, with populist leaders tapping into public resentment toward global elites. These elites, who have amassed unprecedented wealth and power, are seen as the architects of a new world order that benefits the few at the expense of the many. Their support for the US empire’s proxy wars and the neoliberal economic model has only deepened the political divisions in the West.
The current political instability across the United States, the United Kingdom, Germany, France, and Australia reflects a broader crisis of governance in the West. The collapse of traditional political parties, the rise of populism, and the growing disconnect between global elites and the masses suggest that the political structures that have sustained Western democracies for decades may be on the verge of collapse.
As populist leaders continue to gain ground, the future of liberal democracy in the West looks increasingly uncertain. While these leaders may not have all the answers to the complex problems facing Western societies, their opposition to the global elite’s policies, particularly in foreign interventions like those in Ukraine and Palestine, offers a glimmer of hope for a more rational political discourse. However, whether this populist backlash will succeed in reshaping Western politics remains to be seen.
Leave a Reply